
What makes this worth examining is how rarely the decision is made with all the relevant information. Businesses often spend more time comparing supplier rates than evaluating the broker relationship itself, even though the broker can influence which suppliers are approached, how quotes are structured, what gets explained and what support is available between contract events.
Not every broker searches the same part of the market. Some approach a wide range of suppliers, while others work with a smaller panel. The fees and commission arrangements can also differ. Before deciding whether to change, it is worth understanding exactly what your current broker does, how they are paid and whether their service still meets your business’s needs.
What Actually Makes a Business Consider Leaving Its Broker

- Silence between renewals. The first meaningful contact in a year or more is a renewal quote, which can make the business feel that the relationship only exists when there is a transaction to complete.
- Renewal offers that arrive too late. A quote landing only a few weeks before the contract ends leaves limited time to compare options, ask questions or negotiate. The business may feel pressured to accept the first available recommendation.
- Quotes nobody can explain. When asked what is inside the rate, including the unit rate, standing charge, third-party charges and any broker commission, the explanation is vague or incomplete.
- Billing problems with no useful guidance. A strange bill arrives and the broker either does not respond or simply directs the business back to the supplier without helping it understand the issue or identify the appropriate next step. Although the supplier remains responsible for its billing, a broker may provide guidance or offer separate bill validation support.
- The same advice for every business. A small office and a multi-site operation are offered similar contract recommendations because nobody has looked closely enough at their consumption patterns, operating hours, risk appetite or procurement requirements.
- Finding out too late that the contract has ended. The business only discovers that its existing agreement has expired when a different rate or contract arrangement appears on the bill, rather than receiving a timely reminder to review its options.
Why Many Businesses Stay Longer Than They Should

Inertia does most of the work. Changing broker feels like a project with no obvious payoff, particularly when the service is not billed through a separate upfront invoice. There is also a widespread assumption that all brokers are essentially the same because they all approach energy suppliers, which overlooks the fact that brokers can differ significantly in their supplier coverage, comparison process, pricing transparency and ongoing support.
The way a broker is paid is particularly important. Some receive commission from the supplier, which may be included in the costs paid through the energy contract. Others charge the business a direct fee, while some arrangements involve both. A service that appears to be free because there is no separate invoice does not necessarily mean that the broker receives no payment.
For non-domestic energy contracts signed on or after 1 October 2024, suppliers are required to disclose relevant third-party service fees paid through the supplier in the contract’s principal terms and make the information available upon request. Businesses should also ask brokers to explain any direct fees separately. You can read more in Ofgem’s guidance on third-party intermediaries.
It is equally important not to assume that every broker compares the entire market. Some search across a broad range of suppliers, while others work with one supplier or a smaller group. Asking how much of the market was searched, which suppliers were approached and why is a reasonable part of evaluating the service.
Fear of disruption adds to the hesitation. Many businesses worry that changing adviser means changing supplier, risking a gap in supply or triggering a penalty. In practice, these are separate decisions. Changing the broker who advises you does not, by itself, change your energy supplier or terminate your existing supply contract.
What Changing Broker Does and Doesn’t Involve
Moving to a new adviser does not itself interrupt your physical energy supply, because the existing supply arrangement remains with your current supplier. Your existing energy contract will normally continue on its current terms until its end date, unless you separately arrange and complete a supplier switch.
What changes is who advises you on future procurement decisions, who obtains and explains available quotes, and who you approach for support within the scope of the brokerage service.
The new adviser will typically need your authority to access relevant account and contract information, often through a Letter of Authority. Before making the move, check your current brokerage agreement and any existing Letter of Authority for notice requirements, exclusivity provisions, direct fees and how any supplier-paid commission is connected to your existing contract.
Do not assume that changing brokers automatically removes commission already included in an existing supply contract. Equally, do not assume that a new broker can take over every aspect of your account without your authorisation. A good adviser should explain what authority is required, what it covers and what will change before you proceed.
What a Proactive Broker Relationship Looks Like Instead
The difference between a transactional broker and a proactive one shows up in the months when there is nothing to sell. A good adviser should help you keep track of contract end dates across your meters and sites, contact you in sufficient time to consider renewal options, and explain the available supplier offers rather than simply presenting one recommendation.
They should also be able to explain the pricing structure, including the unit rate, standing charge, relevant third-party costs, contract duration and any applicable exit provisions. Where ongoing market support is part of the service, you should understand what information you will receive and how frequently.
Billing support should also be clear. The supplier remains responsible for issuing accurate bills and resolving supplier-side problems, but your broker may help you understand a discrepancy, direct you to the appropriate contact or provide a separate bill validation service.
There is a simple way to test what you currently have. Ask your broker for:
- A list of your contract end dates across every meter and site.
- A clear explanation of which suppliers were approached for your last comparison.
- A breakdown of the broker’s commission or direct fees.
- An explanation of what support you receive between contract renewals.
If the answers are immediate, complete and easy to understand, the relationship may be doing its job. If they take days, arrive with gaps or never arrive, you have learned something important about how your energy costs are being managed.
Who This Hits Hardest
- Businesses that have renewed with the same broker for several cycles without ever asking anyone else for a comparison of the service, not just the price.
- Multi-site businesses where contracts with different end dates have been handled one at a time, with no one holding the whole picture.
- Growing businesses whose energy needs have changed since the relationship began, but whose contract type and advice never did.
- Businesses that discovered an expired contract only after the fact and have never been given a satisfactory explanation of how it happened.
Signs It’s Time to Look Again
- You cannot remember the last time your broker contacted you when there was no renewal to discuss.
- You could not currently state your contract end dates without searching for the paperwork.
- Nobody has ever explained what is inside your rate beyond the headline unit price, including any broker commission or third-party charges.
- Your last billing query went unresolved or took weeks of chasing.
- You do not know which suppliers your broker actually compares or how much of the market they search.
Looking again does not commit you to changing anything. It simply means finding out whether the relationship you have is the one your business needs, before the next renewal makes the decision for you by default.
Review Your Business Energy Broker Arrangement
Ecotilities helps businesses compare available energy supplier options, understand tariff structures and assess procurement choices. Its Bureau Services also include bill validation to identify billing errors or potential rebates.
Before authorising a service, ask for a clear explanation of the suppliers being approached, the options being compared, any applicable commission or direct fees, and the support included in the arrangement.
Visit ecotilities.co.uk/gas-electricity or explore Ecotilities Bill Validation.
Call 0333 2244 050.
Questions Businesses Ask
Will changing broker interrupt our energy supply?
No. Changing the broker who advises you does not itself interrupt your physical energy supply or change your supplier. Your existing supply contract normally continues on its current terms until it ends. A supplier switch is a separate process and would only happen if you decide to arrange one.
Do we have to wait until our contract ends to change broker?
Not necessarily. The relationship with your broker and your energy supply contract are separate arrangements. However, your existing brokerage agreement matters, particularly any notice requirements, exclusivity provisions, direct fees or commission arrangements connected to the contract. Check these before making the move.
How do we know whether our current broker is doing a good job?
Look at how often they contact you outside renewals, how early they present options, whether they explain the pricing structure and whether they can provide a clear breakdown of their fees or commission. Also ask which suppliers they approach and how much of the market they compare. Gaps in any of these areas are worth investigating.
Is it risky to ask another broker for a second opinion?
No. Asking another broker to explain its services or provide an alternative view is normal commercial practice and does not automatically commit you to changing anything. However, be deliberate about sharing account information and signing Letters of Authority. Understand exactly what access you are granting and avoid authorising overlapping arrangements without first checking what they cover.
What information does a new broker need from us?
Typically, your current energy contract details, recent bills, meter information such as MPANs or MPRNs, estimated or historical consumption, and information about the sites covered. The broker may also require a Letter of Authority before approaching suppliers or accessing account information. The exact requirements vary, and the adviser should explain them before you proceed.
Does reviewing our broker relationship cost anything?
Costs depend on the service and payment arrangement. Some brokers receive supplier-paid commission that is reflected in the energy contract, while others charge direct fees or use a combination of both.
Ecotilities’ published terms explain that it receives supplier commission and may also charge fixed brokerage or consultancy fees in applicable cases. Ask for the exact commission and any direct fees that would apply to your business, in writing, before authorising the service. You can review the Ecotilities Terms and Conditions.
